Menger Cat 23 Information, Review, Specs

The Menger Cat 23 began production in 1990 under Menger Boatworks, continuing until 2010. The design lineage traces back to Francis Sweisguth's Americat 22, with the Mengers developing and refining the concept. William Menger, a passionate seaman, founded Menger Boatworks in 1976, driven by a deep love for boats and the shallow waters of Long Island's South Shore. The company built a reputation for crafting comfortable family cruisers and character boats, distinguished by their classic lines and robust fiberglass construction, particularly excelling in light air. A signature feature of Menger boats, including the Cat 23, was their gaff rig, contributing to their traditional appearance.

During its production run, there was a noted variation in displacement. Early hulls were stated to have a displacement of 5,500 lbs, which later increased to 6,500 lbs by 1999. After Menger Boatworks ceased operations in 2004 following William Menger's passing, the legacy of the Menger Cat 23 continued. Jerry Thompson, a former manager at Menger Boatworks, established Thompson Boatworks and took on the building of Menger Cat models, including the Menger Cat 23, often referring to it as the "Thom Cat 23". This transition ensured the enduring availability of these beloved designs.

Sailing Performance and Handling

The Menger Cat 23, with its gaff rig and broad beam (10.0 ft), is known for being stable and forgiving, making it particularly easy to singlehand. The catboat design, characterized by its single, powerful mast-forward sail, typically offers excellent performance in light air. The boat's theoretical maximum hull speed is approximately 6.2 knots, reflecting its displacement hull design. Owners frequently describe the Menger Cat 23 as a vessel that sails flat with minimal heel, contributing to a comfortable experience on the water. Its shoal draft capabilities, facilitated by a centerboard that draws 2.5 feet when raised and 5.5 feet when lowered, allow access to shallow anchorages and enable easier transport. This combination of stability, ease of handling, and shallow draft access makes the Menger Cat 23 a popular choice for coastal cruising and exploring shallower waterways.

Accommodations and Layout

While detailed interior specifications for the Menger Cat 23 are limited in some databases, reviews and owner accounts describe a practical and comfortable layout typical of a cruising catboat of its size. The interior generally features a V-berth forward, providing sleeping accommodations. A small galley area, often equipped with a sink and space for a stove, is typically found, along with an enclosed head compartment for privacy. The main salon usually includes settees that can serve as additional berths, and a modest dinette. The emphasis is on maximizing usable space within its 22.5-foot length overall. Given Menger Boatworks' reputation for quality fiberglass construction, the interior finish generally features durable materials, often incorporating wood trim to maintain the traditional aesthetic. Storage solutions are integrated throughout for extended cruising. With a generous beam of 10 feet, the interior feels more spacious than some monohulls of comparable length, enhancing comfort for weekend trips or short cruises.

Owner's Perspectives

Owners of the Menger Cat 23 frequently praise its robust construction and exceptional stability, noting its ability to stand up to wind and maintain a comfortable motion. The ease of handling, especially for single-handed sailing, is a recurring strength mentioned in owner reviews. The shallow draft, afforded by its centerboard, is another highly valued feature, allowing access to areas inaccessible to deeper keeled boats. The traditional gaff rig is often cited for its powerful performance in light winds and its straightforward nature.

However, as with many boats of its vintage, some common maintenance areas or considerations have been noted by owners. Potential issues might include the aging of original engine components (typically an 18 hp Yanmar diesel), and the need for periodic inspection and maintenance of the centerboard system, including the pennant line. Despite these potential considerations, the Menger Cat 23 maintains an active and loyal community of owners who appreciate its classic lines, forgiving nature, and solid build quality, ensuring the enduring popularity of this unique catboat.